If you’re concerned about eye liner lasting all day or night, make sure your eyes are oil-free before application. After using an oil-free cleanser, apply long-wear, waterproof eyeliner for a look that will last. Packaging is fine, but this eyeliner actually flaked. Not sure why, and I've never seen that happen before... Price was reasonable, but not with the flaking Mary Kay used to ... https://makeupbyoksana.com/